Follow Leafschatter on Twitter

Monday, January 10, 2011

Brian Burke's Next Trade - Part 1

Brian Burke likes to trade for
"big fish" such as Kessel & Phaneuf
It has been fascinating to follow Toronto trade rumours the past two weeks.  Toronto passed on one trade offer for Kris Versteeg while two separate deals for Ryan Parent and Jack Skille fell apart.  Shortly afterwards, Ryan Parent cleared waivers and was assigned to the AHL.  Reports had the deals falling apart because Brian Burke was trying to make them into bigger deals.

In all of this, it was clear; Toronto Maple Leafs fans want to know about the next trade Brian Burke will do.  In short, they want somebody to predict the future for them.

A good way to predict what someone will do in the future is to look at what he did in the past.  In the case of Brian Burke, you can characterize his past trades while managing Toronto in six ways:

  1. Catching the Big Fish
  2. Upgrading the Asset
  3. Cleaning Out the Cap
  4. Making Room for Prospects
  5. Time Machine
  6. Cashing In a Diminishing Asset
Catching the Big Fish

We know these deals as the Phaneuf and Kessel trades.  They come at us completely unexpected.  Suggesting there possibility invites ridicule.  Only Eklund from Hockey Buzz is bold enough to alert us of their possibility.

These deals involve top prospects who delivered elite performances before reaching their prime.  In the case of Phil Kessel, at age 21, he was Boston's leading goal scorer.  For Dion Phaneuf, at the age of 22, he received 1st team all-star honours.  Seeing these type players traded is unthinkable to most people.  Targeting and acquiring them are long shots.  Yet, Brian Burke has done two of these transactions in his first two years as Toronto's manager.

Expect this to be Brian Burke's top trade priority over the next seven weeks.  He has more than enough cap space to do this type of deal.  He is ready to part with quality players such as Clarke MacArthur, Mikhail Grabovski, Nikolai Kulemin, and Kris Versteeg in order to catch that "big fish".

Upgrading the Asset

Turning 24-year-old winger Viktor Stalberg into 24-year-old winger Kris Versteeg by adding two prospects (Chris DiDominico and Philippe Paradis) typifies Brian Burke's asset upgrade trade.  Some people lament the loss of the two prospects.  The fact is, an NHL team can only keep so many prospects under contract with the 50 Active Player roster limit.  It makes it impossible to horde prospects.  Converting 32-year-old Vesa Toskala into 32-year-old J.S. Giguerre last year is another example.

Perhaps Tyler Bozak can be in play in an "Upgrading the Asset" trade.  Toronto can package quality prospects such as Jerry D'Amigo, Matt Frattin, and Kenny Ryan into such a trade.


Cleaning Out the Cap

The packaging of Jason Blake with Vesa Toskala for J.S. Giguerre is Brian Burke's famous "Cleaning out the Cap" trade.  He did it in conjunction with the Dion Phaneuf "Catching the Big Fish" trade to make cap room for Phaneuf and clean out the cap three years out.  Similarly, trading Pavel Kubina for Garnet Exelby created cap space to sign Mike Komisarek and Francois Beauchemin.

Toronto has tremendous cap space.  According to capgeek, there is room to acquire a contract just over $7.538 mil.  This number goes up for Toronto by just over $83k each day.  It will be up to $9.942 mil by the end of January and $16.333 mil by trade deadline.  Toronto has no need for a "Cleaning Out the Cap" trade for this trade deadline period.  But, such a trade can signal an intention to do something "big" during the summer.

Making Room for Prospects

Toronto acquired Matt Lashoff (Boston's 2005 1st round pick) for Stefano Giliati and Alex Berry last August.  Two players least likely to ever make the NHL.  Why?  What happened?

Matt Lashoff is on a one-way contract of $550k and was unlikely to make Tampa's NHL roster.  Tampa's budget is so tight they can't afford to pay $550k to an AHLer.  For Toronto to help Tampa with its budget, Tampa had to help Toronto.  Toronto had 47 spots in its 50 player active roster filled while expecting to add Christian Hanson and Jerry D'Amigo.  Moving both Giliati and Berry allowed Toronto to resign Hanson and add D'Amigo while leaving two spots open for either the trade deadline, college free agent signings, or signing Matt Frattin.

In all likelihood, the deal with Vancouver for Ryan Parent (Nashville's 2005 1st round pick) probably fell apart because Brian Burke would take Ryan Parent's one-way $900k contract only if Vancouver took two low-level prospects such as Dale Mitchell and Robert Slaney in return.

You can characterize trading Jiri Tlusty for junior draft choice Philippe Paradis in the same manner.  It opened up a spot on the the 50 Active Player roster which was used when signing college free agents Brayden Irwin and Ben Scrivens.  In addition, Jiri Tlusty was going to lose his waiver exempt status at the end of that season.  Similarly, Luca Caputi will lose his waiver exempt status at the end of this season.

Time Machine

Trading 21-year-old Jiri Tlusty for 19-year-old Philippe Paradis is an example of a "Time Machine" trade where you convert an asset into a younger asset.  Brian Burke has been trying to do this type of trade with Tomas Kaberle without success.

Coincidently, I have been informed Tomas Kaberle has approved two teams for trade and rejected another two.  It will be interesting to see if Brian Burke can finally pull off a "Time Machine" trade with Tomas Kaberle.

Cashing In a Diminishing Asset

Trading an imminent UFA (Unrestricted Free Agent) for a draft pick or perhaps a prospect can salvage a difficult situation with the player.  The team does not want to extend the player's contract and tries to make the best of it.  Nik Antropov, Dominic Moore, Alexei Ponikoravsky, and Lee Stempniak are Brian Burke examples of such trades.  

Perhaps, Tomas Kaberle and J.S. Giguerre will fall into this category if they waive their no-trade-clause.  However, in a recent radio interview, Brian Burke made it clear he is looking for players.  Not more 2nd round draft picks.

The Stanley Cup Ring Effect

This year, Brian Burke has three assets who have been on a Stanley Cup winning team: Kris Versteeg, Francois Beauchemin, and J.S. Giguerre.  J.S. Giguerre is also a Conn Smythe trophy award winner in 2002-03 for being most valuable player in the playoffs.  These are players coveted by Cup Contenders.  Expect them to be in play at trade deadline.

Don't be surprised if Brian Burke uses these players to target top prospects such as Brayden Schenn and James Van Riemsdyk.  Philadelphia has a most peculiar cap problem.  They have $3.364 mil cap space left on next year's cap.  They can not acquire a player whose contract causes them to exceed next year's cap.  This might be a major reason for Philadelphia trying to outbid everyone on Jamie Langenbrunner.

The Cap/Budget Effect

One characteristic you will find in each major deal done by Brian Burke is a trading partner with salary cap or budget problems.  You should not be surprised to see the same result over the next seven weeks.  

Conclusion

Brian Burke and Toronto Maple Leafs fans may not be on the same page.  You are probably looking for change.  Brian Burke is looking for improvement.  He specifically wants to improve the first line.  He may surprise you by not doing any deals at all if no improvements are made available.  After all, why should he give another team cap or budget relief without receiving anything of significance in return?

Post Script 18-Jan-2011

Brian Burke's Next Trade - Part 2 - Making Room for Prospects

Post Script 2-Feb-2011

Brian Burke's Next Trade - Part 3 - Catching The Big Fish

Post Script 14-Feb-2011

Brian Burke's Next Trade - Part 4 - Tomas Kaberle and the "Time Machine" Trade





Follow @Leafschatter 

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Forget About Leafs Finishing 8th - Think About First!

It is time for Toronto Maple Leafs
to Chase Montreal Canadiens
It is time to change your thinking on the Leafs playoff chase.  Instead of targeting the eighth and final playoff spot, start thinking about first place in Northeast division.  Montreal and Boston are each have 42 points.  One occupies third place while the other is in eighth place.  As a result, a chase for eighth place can easily become a chase for first.


Leafs odds of making the playoffs are presently listed at 1.6% chance.  However, the odds one of Montreal and Boston not making the playoffs is 19.8%.  In short, Leafs chances of making the playoffs depend on either Montreal or Boston faltering.  This is not farfetched. 

Northeast DivisionGPWLOLPTSPTS%GFGA
Montreal Canadiens362014242.5839383
Boston Bruins341911442.6179571
Ottawa Senators371617436.48686108
Buffalo Sabres351417432.45794109
Toronto Maple Leafs341317430.44179103
Ottawa 5.2% and Buffalo 3.6% are closer to a playoff position than Toronto but suffered serious setbacks to their chances by recent injuries.  By the way, these odds do not reflect injuries.  Ottawa's best player,  Jason Spezza, will miss at least six weeks because of a shoulder injury.  Buffalo's top scorer, Derek Roy, is out for the remainder of the season.  In addition, Buffalo's best player, Ryan Miller, has suffered a nagging hip injury and Ottawa has a group of key players over 35 years old (Daniel Alfredsson, Alex Kovalev, and Sergei Gonchar) also suffering from nagging injuries.

With this in mind, you Leafs fans have to ask "How does Toronto stack up against Montreal and Boston?".

Montreal Canadiens

Montreal's fortunes depend on enigmatic Carey Price.  His great performance in October and November pushed Montreal into first place in their division.  But, Montreal will be in trouble if his ordinary performance in December continues for the rest of the season.  Especially if he mirrors last season's finish.

Carey Price Monthly Splits for Last Two Seasons
Year MonthGPWLT/OGASASVSV%GAASO
2009
October
8
2
5
0
25
226
201
.889
3.44
0
November
11
5
4
2
28
358
330
.922
2.48
0
December
8
3
4
1
18
242
224
.926
2.25
0
2010
January
6
1
4
1
18
194
176
.907
3.01
0
February
3
1
1
1
9
80
71
.888
3.76
0
March
5
1
2
1
11
144
133
.924
2.52
0
April
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-
-
0

October1063124272248.9122.381
November1284019392373.9521.593
December1155132307275.8962.910
Montreal has little upside in its top six forward scoring.  In fact, their performance to date is comparable to Toronto's best six forwards.  Most of Montreal's top six forwards have passed their peak performance years (ages 24 to 26) while the ones in their peak years (Kostitsyn and Pouliot) have little upside potential.

Player HtWtAgeGPGAPTS PP SH GW S%
Tomas Plekanec 5-111982835111930 1 0 2 12.0
Michael Cammalleri 5-91822835121527 5 0 2 11.2
Andrei Kostitsyn 6-021425 35 10 13 23 4 0 2 11.2
Brian Gionta 5-7173313612921 2 1 4 8.3
Benoit Pouliot 6-3199243571017 1 0 2 13.5
Scott Gomez 5-11202313451217 2 0 1 8.9
With this present scoring, Montreal's playoff hopes fall squarely upon Carey Price's shoulders.  Montreal will drift down in the standings if Price does not regain his early season form.

Boston Bruins

Boston has been getting spectacular (awesome, miraculous...) goaltending from Tim Thomas and great goaltending from Tuukka Rask.  Yet, there are rumours about Claude Julien's job as Boston's coach being at risk.  Tuukka Rask has a terrible 2-7-1 W-L-OT record in spite of his outstanding .927 save percentage.

Player HtWtAgeGPWLT/OGA SV% GAA SO
Tim Thomas5-112083625174342 .949 1.68 5
Tuukka Rask 6-2171231027124 .927 2.57 1
Team Total 3431911466 .942 1.92 6
Boston is simply not playing good team defence.  They are 25th in NHL Shots Allowed on Goal per Game.  Julien will have an awful mess on his hands if Thomas re-injures his hip.  This is a real risk given Tim Thomas is 36 years old.  To give his age perspective, remember, Quebec Nordiques drafted him in the Entry Draft.

Tim Thomas Monthly Splits for Last Two Seasons
Year
Month
GP
W
L
T/O
GA
SA
SV
SV%
GAA
SO
2009
October
8
4
4
0
23
245
222
.906
2.86
1
November
7
2
2
3
13
180
167
.928
1.80
2
December
9
4
3
2
22
286
264
.923
2.53
1
2010
January
10
3
5
2
24
263
239
.909
2.74
0
February
1
0
1
0
3
25
22
.880
3.06
0
March
7
3
3
1
16
185
169
.914
2.72
0
April
1
0
1
0
3
25
22
.880
3.06
0

October
6
6
0
0
3
185
182
.984
0.50
3
November
9
5
2
1
20
282
262
.929
2.29
1
December
9
5
2
2
17
316
299
.946
1.85
1
Boston has more upside in scoring potential with their young forwards.  Milan Lucic, their top scorer, is only 22 years old!  Three of their other top six forwards are in the prime of their careers.  

Player HtWtAgeGPGAPTS PP SH GW S%
Milan Lucic 6-32282234161127 2 0 3 21.1
David Krejci 6-0177242771724 0 0 1 10.3
Nathan Horton 6-22292534111223 3 0 0 13.6
Michael Ryder 6-01923034101222 6 0 4 13.9
Patrice Bergeron6-2194253471421 3 2 2 8.1
Mark Recchi 5-10 195423461319 4 0 3 10.7
Blake Wheeler 6-520824348614 0 0 2 13.6
Zdeno Chara 6-9255333441014 2 0 0 3.7
Tyler Seguin 6-118218325611 1 0 0 8.5
Marc Savard 5-101913311123 0 0 0 5.3

But, Lucic's scoring stats must be viewed with caution.  He has never scored more than 30 goals in a season all the way back into junior hockey.  His 16 goals scored this season have been inflated by 4 empty net goals.

Ultimately, Boston may have a wild card in Tyler Seguin.  His high potential (second overall draft pick) means the 18 year old has a chance for dramatic improvement in the second half.  Giving this talent every chance to blossom in the second half of the season best serves Boston's playoff aspirations.

Toronto Maple Leafs

Toronto is loaded with youth.  They have the youngest team in the NHL.  Their goal scoring is not far off the pace of Montreal and Boston.  Yet, they wait to realize the significant upside scoring potential on their first line.  Every forward they have under the age of 25 has a good chance of producing better scoring statistics in the second half of the season through natural development.

Player HtWtAgeGPGAPTS PP SH GW S%
Clarke MacArthur 5-11191253491827 3 0 2 15.8
Mikhail Grabovski5-111832634121426 4 0 1 13.3
Kris Versteeg 5-101822433101323 5 0 0 11.5
Nikolai Kulemin6-12252434121022 3 0 2 15.2
Phil Kessel 5-11180233412820 4 1 3 9.0
Tomas Kaberle 6-1214323411920 0 0 1 1.6
Tyler Bozak 6-118324344711 3 0 0 7.5
Dion Phaneuf 6-32142518156 0 0 0 1.8
Nazem Kadri 6-01772017066 0 0 0 0.0
Ultimately, the first line needs rapid development from Nazem Kadri and Tyler Bozak to find his form from last season or perhaps the addition of a veteran player via a player acquisition.

But, any improvement in second half scoring will go for naught if there isn't a dramatic improvement in goaltender performance.  Team defence has been excellent this season.  Toronto has third lowest Shots Allowed per Game average in NHL.

You can rule out 33-year-old J. S. Giguerre as the answer given his chronic groin problem this season.  Toronto's playoff fate now lies in 26-year-old Jonas Gustavsson's hands.  His late season finish last year showed us how well Gustavsson can deliver on his potential.  Now is his moment of truth.

Jonas Gustavsson Monthly Splits for Last Two Seasons
YearMonthGPWLT/OGASASVSV%GAASO
2009October512215139124.8923.22 0
November1043328282254.9013.220
December62129125116.9281.861
2010January1026132288256.8893.360
February101042824.8574.030
March871017222205.9232.060
April201176255.8873.400

October312078982.9212.360
November924222250228.9122.660
December724021153132.8633.780
Toronto Maple Leafs making the playoffs is not as unthinkable as most people want you to believe.  They have youth on their side.  In fact, first place in the division might be just as likely as the playoffs.  It will come down to who has the hottest goaltender.  If Tim Thomas can keep his hip healthy, he might be the hottest goaltender in decades.  In the end, Toronto's playoff hopes might come down to a show down between Jonas Gustavsson and Carey Price in the final game of the season.  If so, it will be one of the most watched games of the season.





Follow @Leafschatter